How We Rate Casinos and Sportsbooks
Licensing first, then an average of independent expert scores, with every source linked. Here is exactly how our ratings work.
Our job is to help you choose a casino or sportsbook that is legal where you are and well regarded by people who review these sites for a living. This page explains exactly how we do that, including what our ratings are and what they are not.
Step 1: The licensing check
Before a brand can appear anywhere on the site, we check it on the official register for each province we cover:
- Ontario: iGaming Ontario’s directory of regulated sites, operated under the Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario.
- Alberta: the Alberta iGaming Corporation’s directory of registered sites, regulated by AGLC.
- Rest of Canada: for players outside Ontario and Alberta, we only list long-established brands that hold a documented Kahnawake Gaming Commission or equivalent licence, and we say clearly on each review that this is not provincial regulation.
This is a pass/fail check, not part of the score. If a brand is not on the Ontario register, it never appears on our Ontario lists, and the links on our pages always send you to the brand’s site for your province.
Step 2: How our star ratings work
Each brand’s star rating is the average of the overall scores published by up to 10 established review sites that cover the Canadian market. We collect each site’s overall score for the brand, convert it to a 5-point scale (a 9/10 becomes 4.5, a 32/40 becomes 4.0) and average the results to one decimal place.
- Expert reviews only. We leave out user-review platforms such as Trustpilot and app-store ratings. Those mostly reflect how many unhappy customers chose to post, and they are useful as a warning sign but not as a comparison score.
- Every source is shown. Each review page lists every score we used, the site it came from and a link to that review, so you can check our work.
- Rankings follow the averages. Within the brands registered for your province, our lists are ordered by star rating.
- What the rating is not. It is a summary of expert opinion, not the result of our own hands-on test, and we do not mark it up as our own rating in search results.
Some smaller or newer brands are reviewed by fewer sites, so their average is based on fewer scores. The number of sites behind each rating is shown next to the stars.
Step 3: The facts on each review
Alongside the rating, each review summarizes the facts players ask about most. We compile them from official registers, the operator’s own pages and help centres, and published reviews:
| Fact | Where it comes from |
|---|---|
| Licensing and operator company | Provincial registers and the operator’s terms |
| Payment methods | Operator help centres and published reviews of each provincial site |
| Minimum deposit and typical payout time | Published reviews; payout times are figures reported for verified accounts |
| Game library and founding year | Operator information and published reviews |
| What reviewers like and criticise | A summary of the points that appear repeatedly across independent reviews |
Where providers change, we update. Instadebit, for example, closed in 2026, so we removed it from every brand’s payment list.
Step 4: Re-checks and removals
Every review shows the date its facts were last verified, and we re-check licensing and key facts at least every 90 days. We remove a brand from a province’s lists as soon as we confirm it has lost its registration there. We also mention regulatory fines and disciplinary action in the relevant review, and we re-collect review-site scores when we re-check a brand, so ratings move as expert opinion moves.
Hands-on testing
We are building a program of our own hands-on tests: opening accounts, depositing, playing and timing withdrawals. When a brand has been tested, its review will say so clearly, show the date of the test and our own score separately from the review-site average. Until then, we do not claim results we have not measured.
Sportsbooks
Sportsbooks go through the same licensing check and rating method. On sportsbook reviews and betting guides we also explain the things that matter most to bettors: market depth on the NHL, NFL, NBA and CFL, live betting and cash-out, bet builders, and the margin built into the odds, which you can calculate with our odds converter.
Editorial independence
We earn commissions from some brands when readers sign up through our links. That is how the site is funded. Commercial relationships cannot buy a rating, a higher position or a change to a review: rankings follow the licensing check and the review-site average described above, and the sources are published so anyone can verify them. Read our affiliate disclosure and editorial policy.
Who writes our content
- Dan Goldsmith, Editor, oversees the site’s main pages and the licensing checks.
- Jacob Mueller, Casino Reviewer, compiles our brand reviews, payment lists and ratings.
- Emily Zacks, Guides Writer, writes our guides to games, betting and responsible gambling.
Spotted something out of date?
Operators change their cashiers, terms and games regularly. If you find a fact on our site that is no longer correct, email [email protected] and we will check and correct it.